A great night’s sleep can make or break a guest’s experience—so for Airbnb hosts, the mattress isn’t just a piece of furniture, it’s a strategic investment. While it’s tempting to cut costs, a cheap or uncomfortable mattress can lead to negative reviews, lower star ratings, and fewer repeat bookings. On the flip side, splurging on a high-end bed might not pay off if it wears quickly or isn’t universally comfortable. The sweet spot lies in a balance: durability, comfort for most guests, and a price point that still supports profit margins. To help navigate this decision, we analyzed over 150 detailed host testimonials and product recommendations from other active Airbnb, VRBO, and STR owners across several discussion forums and surveys

Based on those real-world insights, the following curated list highlights 6 mattress models that consistently earn guest praise, hold up to repeated use, and won’t blow your furnishing budget. Plus, based on reviews - it is all about the COMBO of the right mattress and the right topper…so we’re adding the top 2 mattress toppers that make the sweet combo for those 5 star reviews!